Insider threat is one of the most uncomfortable topics in cybersecurity because it forces us to confront a truth that no one likes to admit. The biggest risk to an organization is not always a nation state or a ransomware gang. Sometimes it is the person who already has a badge, already has access, and already understands exactly how your systems work.
For years, companies have responded to insider threats by buying more tools, adding more monitoring, and tightening more controls. These are important, but they ignore the most powerful variable in the entire equation. Human motivation.
People become insiders when the perceived benefits outweigh the perceived risks. If you change that equation, you change the outcome. And one of the most effective ways to change that equation is through financial incentives, cultural reinforcement, and structural controls that make malicious behavior less appealing and legitimate behavior more rewarding.
This is not theory. It is supported by research and guidance from organizations like FINRA, which notes that insider threats often increase when employee satisfaction decreases and when workforce reductions or compensation issues create frustration or disengagement inside the organization, as described in Insider Threats Effective Controls and Practices from FINRA.org. It is also reinforced by the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency, which highlights the financial and organizational costs of insider incidents and the importance of building programs that address both human and technical factors, as outlined in the Insider Threat Mitigation Guide from CISA .
So let us break down the financial, psychological, and structural incentives that actually keep people from becoming insiders or handing over their credentials.
The Financial Side of Insider Prevention
Competitive and Transparent Compensation
Underpaid employees are more vulnerable to bribery, credential sharing, and data theft. When someone feels financially stable, the offer from an attacker looks far less attractive. FINRA specifically notes that industry wide trends like reductions in workforce and bonuses can increase insider threat risk because they reduce employee satisfaction and engagement, which in turn increases susceptibility to malicious influence, as described in Insider Threats Effective Controls and Practices from FINRA.org .
Organizations that want to reduce insider risk should benchmark compensation against industry standards, adjust for inflation, and provide retention bonuses for high risk roles such as identity administrators, cloud engineers, and support staff who have broad access to sensitive systems.
Financial Rewards for Reporting Recruitment Attempts
This is one of the most powerful tools that organizations rarely use. Attackers often reach out to employees with offers of quick money in exchange for credentials or access. But imagine if the company offered the same amount or more for reporting the attempt instead of accepting it.
This flips the economics instantly. Reporting becomes the most profitable option. It also generates intelligence on threat actors and deters attackers who realize employees are financially incentivized to expose them.
CISA emphasizes the importance of understanding the costs of insider threats and the return on investment for mitigation programs, which includes proactive measures that reduce the likelihood of malicious activity, as described in the Insider Threat Mitigation Guide from CISA .
Spot Bonuses for Integrity
Security should not be invisible. When employees report suspicious behavior, prevent an incident, or demonstrate exceptional adherence to security controls, they should be recognized and rewarded. This builds a culture where security is not just expected but appreciated.
Emergency Assistance Programs
Attackers prey on desperation. Medical bills, debt, and family emergencies create vulnerabilities that can be exploited. A company sponsored emergency fund or no interest loan program removes the leverage attackers rely on. It also signals that the organization cares about its people, which reduces resentment and increases loyalty.
The Psychological and Cultural Side of Insider Prevention
Employees Who Feel Valued Are Less Likely To Become Insiders
FINRA notes that insider threats often rise when employees feel disengaged or dissatisfied, which can happen during periods of turnover, reduced bonuses, or organizational instability, as described in Insider Threats Effective Controls and Practices from FINRA.org . People who feel respected, supported, and recognized are dramatically less likely to betray the organization.
Toxic cultures produce more insider incidents than high stress technical environments. The difference is not the workload. It is the emotional environment.
Normalize Reporting Without Fear
Employees should feel that reporting suspicious outreach is expected, appreciated, and safe. If reporting feels risky, people stay silent. Silence is where insider threats grow.
Reduce Fear of Punishment for Early Mistakes
Many insider incidents begin with a small mistake that someone tries to hide. A policy that encourages early reporting without punishment prevents escalation. It also builds trust between employees and security teams.
The Structural Side of Insider Prevention
Financial and cultural incentives matter, but structural controls change the risk side of the equation. They make malicious behavior harder, riskier, and less profitable.
Just In Time Access
If employees do not have standing access, they cannot sell it. Access is granted only when needed and only for the duration of the task.
Dual Control for Sensitive Actions
Requiring two people for high risk operations makes bribery more expensive and more complicated. It also reduces the likelihood that a single insider can cause significant damage.
Privileged Session Monitoring
When employees know their actions are visible, the perceived risk increases. This alone deters many potential insiders.
Credential Less Workflows
The fewer reusable credentials that exist, the less there is to steal or sell. Modern identity systems make this increasingly achievable.
The Most Effective Programs Combine All Three
The organizations with the lowest insider threat rates combine financial incentives, cultural reinforcement, and structural controls. CISA emphasizes that effective insider threat programs require a combination of organizational policies, human behavioral understanding, and technical controls, as described in the Insider Threat Mitigation Guide from CISA .
Financial incentives change the benefits.
Cultural incentives change the motivations.
Structural controls change the risks.
When all three are aligned, insider recruitment collapses.
Banks and financial institutions have learned this the hard way. Insider threats can undermine even the most robust anti-financial crime programs because insiders understand the systems and can bypass controls, as described in The Threat From Within from the ABA Banking Journal . This is why financial institutions increasingly focus on employee behavior, ethics, and incentives, not just monitoring tools.
Final Thoughts
Insider threat mitigation is not just a technical problem. It is an economic and psychological one. You cannot monitor your way out of insider risk. You have to change the incentives that drive human behavior.
When employees feel valued, supported, fairly compensated, and rewarded for integrity, the idea of betraying the organization becomes far less appealing. When access is limited, monitored, and controlled, the opportunity for malicious behavior shrinks. And when reporting suspicious activity is financially rewarded, attackers lose their leverage.
The most effective insider threat programs are not built on fear. They are built on trust, transparency, and incentives that make doing the right thing the most rewarding choice.
Sources
FINRA. Insider Threats Effective Controls and Practices.
https://www.finra.org/rules-guidance/guidance/reports/insider-threats-effective-controls-and-practices (finra.org in Bing)
CISA. Insider Threat Mitigation Guide.
https://www.cisa.gov/resources-tools/resources/insider-threat-mitigation-guide (cisa.gov in Bing)
ABA Banking Journal. The Threat From Within: Managing Insider Threat Risks.
https://bankingjournal.aba.com/2025/07/the-threat-from-within-managing-insider-threat-risks (bankingjournal.aba.com in Bing)
Leave a Reply