What to Do When You Identify an Insider Threat

Insider threats are among the most difficult risks to manage. Unlike external attackers, insiders already have legitimate access, understand internal processes, and can bypass many traditional defenses. Whether the threat is malicious, negligent, or the result of compromised credentials, the way you respond can determine whether the damage is contained or spirals into a full-scale incident.

Below is a structured approach for handling insider threats once they’ve been identified.

1. Confirm and Contain Immediately

• Validate the signal: Use multiple data points (logs, DLP alerts, behavioral analytics) to confirm the activity is truly suspicious and not a false positive.
• Limit access: Restrict the insider’s access to sensitive systems and data as quickly as possible without tipping them off unnecessarily.
• Preserve evidence: Ensure logs, communications, and system activity are captured before containment actions alter them.

2. Escalate Through the Right Channels

• Notify your insider threat response team (or equivalent SOC/IR team).
• Engage HR and Legal early: Insider cases often involve employment law, contracts, and potential litigation.
• Involve leadership: Executives should be aware of potential business impact, especially if customer or regulatory data is involved.

3. Investigate with Precision

• Scope the activity: Determine what data, systems, or processes were accessed or exfiltrated.
• Identify intent: Was this malicious, negligent, or the result of stolen credentials?
• Timeline reconstruction: Map out when the activity began, how it progressed, and whether it’s ongoing.
• Cross-check with HR data: Look for stressors such as performance issues, financial pressure, or recent disciplinary actions that may correlate with malicious intent.

4. Remediate and Recover

• Revoke or adjust access: Remove unnecessary privileges and rotate credentials.
• Patch process gaps: If negligence was the cause (e.g., misconfigured cloud storage), fix the root issue.
• Communicate carefully: If customers, regulators, or partners are affected, follow disclosure requirements while minimizing reputational damage.
• Support employees: In cases of negligence, training and awareness may be more effective than punitive measures.

5. Learn and Strengthen

• Update detection rules: Feed new indicators back into your SIEM, UEBA, or insider threat platform.
• Refine policies: Adjust acceptable use, monitoring, and access control policies.
• Conduct a post-incident review: Document lessons learned and share them with stakeholders.
• Invest in culture: A strong security culture reduces negligence and encourages employees to report suspicious behavior.

Key Takeaway

Identifying an insider threat is only the beginning. The real test is how quickly and effectively you contain, investigate, and remediate the situation. By combining technical controls, cross-departmental coordination, and cultural reinforcement, organizations can reduce both the likelihood and the impact of insider incidents.

Want more practical strategies for defending against insider threats?